Rabbi Singer claims Matthew twisted Micah 5:2 to fake a Bethlehem birth prophecy about the Messiah — but did he tell you what other rabbis actually say? You'll walk through the Hebrew text, Matthew's citation, and two major rabbinic sources — Lamentations Rabbah and Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer — that directly support a Bethlehem-born, preexistent Messiah. By the end, you'll see exactly which traditional Jewish texts Rabbi Singer left out and why they matter.